TRADITIONAL-CONTEMPORARY’ COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT APPROACHES FOR EFFECTIVE LOCAL CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION IN INDONESIA

Meuthia Naim, Richard Hindmarsh

Abstract


The current problem of inadequate (or ineffective) community engagement in Indonesia poses a major policy gap for the Indonesian endeavour to develop effective climate change adaptation. This gap needs addressing for robust adaptation to occur in a country highly vulnerable to extreme weather events and changing weather patterns. Currently, 65% of the Indonesian population (of some 265 million) reside on the coast with many dependent upon natural resources for their livelihoods. As climate change strengthens, effective participatory climate change adaptation – here with the focus on inclusive and active local community engagement – needs development as a priority to reduce the high vulnerability of communities and to achieve resilient communities. To close this policy gap – as informed by historical analysis, archival materials, and interview data – we posit that local community engagement approaches that integrate traditional and contemporary (or “old” and “new”) engagement practices and approaches offer much promise for local community adaptation effectiveness in the case of Indonesia. Such approaches we also posit should have relevance for other traditional-contemporary informed societies, as most evident in developing countries.

 


Keywords


Community engagement, climate change adaptation, traditional and contemporary, Indonesia

Full Text:

PDF

References


(1) MOE (Ministry of the Environment). National action plan in addressing climate change. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment; 2007

(2) Bappenas 2008. National development planning: Indonesia’s responses to climate change. Jakarta: Bappenas; 2008

(3) Yusuf A, Francisco H. Climate change vulnerability mapping for Southeast Asia. Singapore: The Economy and Environment Program for Southeast Asia; 2009.

(4) BMKG (Indonesian Agency for Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics). Press releases and information [Internet]. BMKG; 2017 [cited 23 November 2017]. Available from: http://www.bmkg.go.id/?lang=EN

(5) Sukardjo S. Integrated coastal zone management ICZM in Indonesia: A view from a mangrove ecologist. Southeast Asian Studies. 2002;40:200–218.

(6) CIFOR (Center for International Forestry Research). Mainstreaming adaptation to climate change into the development agenda: Policy and scientific challenges. Report of the Regional Kick-off Meeting of TroFCCA Southeast Asia. Bogor: CIFOR; 23 May 2006.

(7) BPS. Statistik sumber daya laut dan pesisir. Statistics of marine and coastal resources. Jakarta: BPS; Desember 2017. 352p.

(8) Field CB, VR Barros, DJ Dokken, KJ Mach, MD Mastrandrea, TE Bilir, et al. Climate change 2014: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. UK: Cambridge University Press; 2014.

(9) IPCC (International Panel for Climate Change). Climate change 2014: Impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability: Summary for policymakers. Working Group II Contribution to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2014. 34p.

(10) UK United Kingdom Government. Environmental management: Flooding and coastal change. [Internet]. 2014 [cited 23 November 2017]. Available from: https://www.gov.uk/topic/environmental-management/flooding-coastal-change

(11) Smit B, Wandel J. Adaptation, adaptive capacity and vulnerability. Glbal Env Chnge. 2006;16:282–292.

(12) Moser S, Dilling L. Creating a climate for change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 2007

(13) IPCC. Climate Change 2014: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Geneva: IPCC; 2014. 151 pp.

(14) ADB. Poverty in Indonesia [Internet]. Metro Manila: ADB; 2019 [cited 21 February 2019]. Available from: https://www.adb.org/countries/indonesia/poverty

(15) Adger WN. Social capital, collective action, and adaptation to climate change. Econ Geog. 2003;79:387–404.

(16) Van Aalst M, Cannon T, Burton I. Community level adaptation to climate change: The potential role of participatory community risk assessment. Global Environ Chang. 2008;18:165–179.

(17) UN. UN Cancun Adaptation Framework. Report of the conference of the parties on its sixteenth session, Cancun 2010. Cancun: UN; 2011. Report No.: FCCC/CP/2010/7/Add.1.

(18) Kusters K. Climate-smart landscapes and the landscape approach – an exploration of the concepts and their practical implications. Wageningen: Tropenbos International; 2015.

(19) Yoseph-Paulus R, Hindmarsh R. Addressing inadequacies of sectoral coordination and local capacity building in Indonesia for effective climate change adaptation. Clim Dev. 2016. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1080/17565529.2016.1184609

(20) Djalante R, Thomalla F, Sinapoy MS, Carnegie M. Building resilience to natural hazards in Indonesia: Progress and challenges in implementing the Hyogo Framework for Action. Nat Hazards. 2012;62:779–803.

(21) Quick K, Feldman M. 2011. Distinguishing participation and inclusion. Journal of Plan Ed and Res. 2011;31:272–290.

(22) Levi-Faur D, Vigoda-Gadot E, editors. 2004. International public policy and management: Policy learning beyond regional, cultural, and political boundaries. New York: Marcel Dekker; 2004.

(23) Hall M. Policy learning and policy failure in sustainable tourism governance: From first- and second-order to third-order change? JOST. 2011;19:649–671.

(24) Devine-Wright P, Batel S. My neighbourhood, my country or my planet? The influence of multiple place attachments and climate change concern on social acceptance of energy infrastructure. Global Environ Chang. 2017;47:110–120.

(25) Spink A, Hillman M, Fryirs K, Brierley G, Lloyd K. Has river rehabilitation begun? Social perspectives from the Upper Hunter catchment, New South Wales, Australia. Geoforum. 2010;41:399–409.

(26) Hindmarsh R. ‘Liberating’ social knowledges for water management, and more broadly environmental management, through place-change planning. Local Environ. 2012;17:1121–1136.

(27) Naim, M (Meuthia). Effective community engagement for climate change adaptation in Indonesia. Thesis (PhD). Brisbane: Griffith University. 2013.

(28) Smiley S, de Loē R, Kreutzwiser R. Appropriate public involvement in local environmental governance: A framework and case study. Soc Nat Resour. 2010; 23: 1043–1059.

(29) Dermont C, Ingold K, Kammermann L, Stadelmann-Steffen I. Bringing the policy making perspective in: A political science approach to social acceptance. Energ Policy. 2017; 108: 359–368.

(30) Selin C, Rawlings KC, Ridder-Vignone K, Sadowski J, Allende CA, Gano G, et al. 2017. Experiments in engagement: Designing public engagement with science and technology for capacity building. Public Underst Sci. 2017; 26: 634–649.

(31) Skogstad G. Legitimacy and/or policy effectiveness? J Eur Public Policy. 2003;10: 321–338.

(32) Browner KH. Water resources in Australia: Deliberation on options for protection and management. AJEM. 2014;21:228–240.

(33) Quick K, Feldman M. Distinguishing participation and inclusion. J Plan Educ Res. 2011;31:272–290.

(34) Souza D, Yieidoe EK. Social acceptance of wind energy development and planning in rural communities of Australia: A consumer analysis. Energ Policy. 2014; 74, 262–270.

(35) Edwards P, Hindmarsh R, Mercer H, Bond M, Rowland A. A three-stage evaluation of a deliberative event on climate change and transforming energy. JPD [Internet] 2008 [cited 23 November 2017]; 4, Article 6. Available from: http://services.bepress.com/jpd/vol4/iss1/art6

(36) Wiseman J, Williamson L. Community engagement and climate change: Learning from recent Australian experience. Int J Clim Chang Str. 2009; 2: 134–147.

(37) Connick S, Innes J. Outcomes of collaborative water policy making: Applying complexity thinking to evaluation. J Environ Plann Man. 2003; 46: 177–197

(38) Melo M, Baiocchi G. Deliberative democracy and local governance: Towards a new agenda. IJURR. 2006; 30, 587–600.

(39) Walker G, Devine-Wright P, Hunter S, High H, Evans B. Trust and community: Exploring the meanings, contexts and dynamics of community renewable energy. Energ Policy. 2010; 38: 2655–2663.

(40) Few R, Brown K, Tompkins E. Public participation and climate change adaptation. London: Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. 2006. Working Paper 95.

(41) Birkmann J, Garschagen M, Kraas F, Quang N. Adaptation urban governance: New challenges for the second generation of urban adaptation strategies to climate change. Sustain Sci. 2010; 5: 185–206.

(42) Cone J, Rowe S, Borberg J, Stancioff E, Doore B, Grant K. Reframing engagement methods for climate change adaptation. Coast Manage. 2013; 41: 345–360.

(43) Proshansky H, Fabian A, Kaminoff R. Place-identity: Physical world socialization of the self. J. Environ. Psychol. 1983; 3: 57–83.

(44) Wester-Herber M. Underlying concerns in land-use conflicts: The role of place-identity in risk perception. Environ Sci Policy. 2004;7:109–116.

(45) Wolsink M. Planning of renewable schemes: Deliberative and fair decision-making on landscape issues instead of reproachful accusations of non-cooperation. Energ Policy. 2007; 35: 2692–2704.

(46) Eversole R. Knowledge partnering for community development. New York: Routledge. 2015.

(47) Smith G. Deliberative democracy and the environment. London: Routledge. 2003.

(48) Bradley L, Parker R. Organisational culture in the public sector. Melbourne: Institute of Public Administration. 2007.

(49) Measham T, Preston B, Smith T, Brooke C, Gorddard R, Withycombe G, et al. Adapting to climate change through local municipal planning: Barriers and challenges. Mitig Adapt Strat Gl. 2011;16:889–909.

(50) Duram L, Brown K. Assessing public participation in U.S. watershed planning initiatives. Soc Nat Res. 1999;12: 455–467.

(51) Suryadinata L, Arifin EN, Ananta A. Indonesia’s population: Ethnicity and religion in a changing political landscape. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. 2003.

(52) Hellwig T, Tagliacozzo E, editors. The Indonesia reader: History, culture, politics. London: Duke University Press; 2009.

(53) Wever L, Glaser M, Gorris P, Ferrol-Schulte D. Decentralization and participation in integrated coastal management: Policy lessons from Brazil and Indonesia. Ocean Coast Manage. 2012; 66: 63–72.

(54) Geertz H. Indonesian cultures and communities. In: R McVey, editor. Indonesia. New Haven: HRAF Press; 1963.

(55) Koentjaraningrat, editor. Manusia dan Kebudayaan di Indonesia [Human culture in Indonesia]. Jakarta: Djambatan; 1975.

(56) Hefner R. Introduction: Multiculturalism and citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia. In R. Hefner, editor. The politics of multiculturalism: Pluralism and citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press; 2001. p. 1–58.

(57) Drakeley S. The history of Indonesia. Westport: Greenwood; 2005.

(58) Koentjaraningrat. Some Social-anthropological observations on gotong royong practices in two villages of Central Java. New York: Cornell Modern Indonesia Project; 1961.

(59) Sullivan J. Local government and community in Java: An urban case-study. Singapore: Oxford University Press; 1992.

(60) Naim M. Demokrasi dalam Dialektika Kebudayaan Nusantara: Ceramah Budaya. [Democracy in Nusantara culture dialectic: A cultural speech]. Jakarta: Dewan Kesenian Jakarta; 1994.

(61) Bowen J. On the political construction of tradition: Gotong royong in Indonesia. J Asian Stud. 1986;45: 545–561

(62) Soemardjan S, Breazeale K. Cultural change in Rural Indonesia: Impact of village development. Surakarta, Indonesia: Kentingan; 1993.

(63) Hatta M. Our democracy. Jakarta: Pustaka Antara; 1966.

(64) Noer D. The development of our democracy. Jakarta: Prisma; 1977.

(65) Naim M. Quo Vadis Sumatera Barat dengan Adat dan Budaya Minangkabaunya? [Quo Vadis West Sumatera with its Minangkabau’s customary laws and culture?]. Jakarta: Majelis Pembina Adat Alam Minangkabau; 2000.

(66) Taylor J. Indonesia: Peoples and histories. New Haven: Yale University Press; 2003.

(67) Darmaputera E. Pancasila and the search for identity and modernity in Indonesian society: A cultural and ethical analysis. Leiden: E.J. Brill; 1988.

(68) Gouda F. Dutch culture overseas: Colonial practice in the Netherlands Indies 1900–1942. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press; 1995.

(69) Feith H. The decline of constitutional democracy in Indonesia. Ithaca: Cornell University Press; 1962.

(70) Irwin A. The politics of talk: coming to terms with the ‘new’ scientific governance. Soc Stud Sci. 2006; 36: 299–320.

(71) Crouch H. The Army and politics in Indonesia. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press; 1978.

(72) Aspinall E. The broadening base of political opposition in Indonesia. In: Rodan G, editor. Political opposition in industrialising Asia. New York: Routledge; 1996. p.175–195. 1996.

(73) Bourchier D, Hadiz,V, editors. Indonesian politics and society: A reader. London: RoutledgeCurzon. 2003.

(74) Chalmers I. Indonesia: An introduction to contemporary traditions. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006.

(75) Bunte M, Ufen Y, editors. Democratization in Post-Suharto Indonesia. London: Routledge; 2009.

(76) Wibowo E, Nogi H. Kebijakan Publik dan Budaya [Public policy and culture]. Yogyakarta: Yayasan Pembaruan Administrasi Publik Indonesia; 2004.

(77) Okten C, Osili U. Contributions in heterogeneous communities: Evidence from Indonesia. J Popul Econ. 2004;17:603–626.

(78) Warren C. Mapping common futures: Customary communities, NGOs and the state in Indonesia’s reform era. Dev Change. 2005; 36: 49–73.

(79) Wade R. The Asian debt-and-development crisis of 1997–1998: Causes and consequences. World Development. 1998; 26, 1535–1553.

(80) Usman S. 2002. Regional autonomy in Indonesia: Field experiences and emerging challenges. Paper presented at the 7th PRSCO Summer Institute/The 4th IRSA International Conference: Decentralization, Natural Resources and Regional Development in the Pacific Rim. Bali: 2002,20–21 June.

(81) Siry H. Decentralized coastal zone management in Malaysia and Indonesia: A comparative perspective. Coast Manage. 2006; 34, 267–285. 2006.

(82) Wibawa S. Good governance dan Otonomi Daerah. [Good governance and regional autonomy]. Yogyakart: Gadjah Mada University Press; 2008.

(83) Hadiz, V., 2004. Decentralization and democracy in Indonesia: A critique of neo-institutionalist perspectives. Development and Change, 3, 697–718

(84) Thorburn, C., 2002. Decentralization and resource management in Indonesia. Soc Nat Res. 2002; 15, 617–628.

(85) Boardman R, Shaw T. Protecting the environment in Indonesia: Policies and programs. In: O Dwivedi, D. Vajpeyi, editors. Environmental policies in the third world: A comparative analysis. Connecticut: Greenwood Press; 1995. p. 86–124.

(86) Gordon J. NGOs, the environment and political pluralism in New Order Indonesia. Explorations in Southeast Asian Studies; 1998. 2. p. 1–26

(87) MOE. Sejarah dan latar belakang Kementerian Lingkungan Hidup [History of the Ministry of Environment]. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment. 2011.

(88) Hardjasoemantri K. Menjelang sepuluh tahun undang-undang lingkungan hidup [Towards ten years of the Environment Act]. Yogyakarta: Gadjah Mada University Press; 1992.

(89) Princen T, Finger M. Introduction. In: T. Princen and M. Finger, editors. Environmental NGOs in world politics: Linking the local to the global. New York: Routledge; 2005. p. 1–28.

(90) Ahmad M. 2006. Gerakan ornop lingkungan di Indonesia [Environmental NGO movement in Indonesia]. Jentera. 2006; 3: 22–41.

(91) WALHI Indonesian Forum for the Environment [Internet]. Jakarta: WALHI; nd [cited 23 November 2017]. Available from: http://forestcompass.org/who/indonesian-forum-environment-walhi

(92) Eccleston B, Potter D. Environmental NGOs and different political contexts in South-East Asia: Malaysia, Indonesia and Vietnam. In: M. Parnwell, R. Bryant, editors. Environmental change in South-East Asia: People, politics and sustainable development. London: Routledge; 1996. p. 46–63.

(93) Harwell, E., 2000. Remote sensibilities: Discourses of technology and the making of Indonesia’s natural disaster. Dev Change. 2000; 31: 307–340.

(94) Okamoto S. The movement and activities of environmental NGOs in Indonesia. Hayama: Institute for Global Environmental Strategies; 2001.

(95) Nomura K. 2007. Democratisation and environmental non-governmental organisations in Indonesia. J Contemp Asia. 2007; 37: 495–517.

(96) MOE. Jaringan dokumentasi dan informasi hukum [Documentation and information network]. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment. 2009

(97) Crawford B.R, Siahaninenia A, Rotinsulu C, Sukmara A. Compliance and enforcement of community-based coastal resource management regulations in North Sulawesi, Indonesia. Coast Manage. 2004; 32: 39–50.

(98) Tulungen J, Devi B, Rotinsulu D. 2000. Pengembangan, persetujuan dan pelaksanaan rencana pembangunan dan pengelolaan sumberdaya Wilayah Pesisir Berbasis-Masyarakat di Sulawesi Utara [Development, approval and implementation of community-based management and development plans in North Sulawesi Province]. Paper presented at Konferensi Nasional II: pengelolaan sumberdaya pesisir dan lautan. [National Conference II: Management of Coastal and Marine Resources]. Makassar. 15–17 May 2000.

(99) Glaser M, Baitoningsih W, Ferse S, Neil M, Deswandi R. Whose sustainability? Top-down participation and emergent rules in marine protected area management in Indonesia. Mar. Policy. 2010; 34: 1215–1225.

(100) Elliott G, Mitchell B, Wiltshire B, Manan A, Wismer S. Community participation in marine protected area management: Wakatobi National Park, Sulawesi, Indonesia. Coast Manage. 2010; 29: 295–316.

(101) Ferse S, Costa M, Manez K, Adhuri D, Glaser M. Allies, not aliens: Increasing the role of local communities in marine protected area implementation. Environ Conserv. 2010; 37: 23–34.

(102) Musadar. Partisipasi masyarakat dalam pembangunan hutan kemasyarakatan di Kabupaten Kolaka [Community participation in community forest development in the Kolaka District]. Agriplus. 2005; 15: 133–140.

(103) Fitriadi, Gunawan T, Rijanta, Peran pemerintah dan partisipasi masyarakat dalam rehabilitasi hutan mangrove: Kasus Kecamatan Pemangkat, Kabupaten Sambas, Kalimantan Barat [The role of government and community participation in mangrove rehabilitation: A case study of Pemangkat Sub-District, Sambas District, West Kalimantan]. JML. 2005; 12: 122–129.

(104) Diposaptono S. Climate change adaptation in coastal areas based on local issues and community participation: Case study Demak District, Indonesia. Paper presented at The East Asian Seas Congress, 23–17 November 2009, Manila, The Philippines.

(105) Desmawan BT, Sukamdi. Adaptasi masyarakat kawasan pesisir terhadap banjir rob di Kecamatan Sayung, Kabupaten Demak, Jawa Tengah [Adaptation of coastal communities on floods due to sea level rise in Sayung Sub-district, Demak District, Central Java Province]. JBI [Internet]. 2012 [cited 23 November 2017];1(1). Available from: http://goo.gl/2kR0k7

(106) Bappenas. Strategy for mainstreaming climate adaptation into sector-specific national development plan. Jakarta: Bappenas; 2012.

(107) Damaywanti K. Dampak abrasi pantai terhadap lingkungan sosial: studi kasus di Desa Bedono, Sayung Demak [The impact of coastal abrasion on social environment: the case study of Bedono Village, Sayung Demak], Seminar Proceedings, Nasional Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Alam dan Lingkungan 2013 [National Seminar on Natural Resources and Environmental Management 2013], Universitas Diponegoro, Semarang.

(108) MOE. Program kampung iklim [Climate village program]. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment; 2010.

(109) MOE. Proklim: Program kampung iklim [Proklim: The climate village program]. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment. 2015.

(110) Lassa J, Nugraha E. From shared learning to shared action in building resilience in the city of Bandar Lampung, Indonesia. Environ Urban.2015; 0: 1–20. Available from: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0956247814552233 DOI: 10.1177/0956247814552233.

(111) Taylor J, Lassa J. How can climate change vulnerability assessments best impact policy and planning? Lessons from Indonesia. Asian Cities Climate Resilience. London: IIED; 2015. Working Paper Series 22.

(112) Antlov H. Village government and rural development in Indonesia. BIES. 2003; 39: 193–214.

(113) Sullivan J. Inventing and imagining community: Two modern Indonesian ideologies. Monash University, Clayton: Centre of Southeast Asian Studies; 1991.

(114) Brooks K. Social capital: Analysing the effect of a political perspective on the perceived role of government in community prosperity. Rural Soc. 2007; 17: 231–247.

(115) Fox RB. 1979. The Philippines in prehistoric times. In: M Garcia, editor. Readings in Philippine prehistory. Manila: The Filipina Book Guild; 1979. p. 35–61.

(116) Taylor J. A tale of two cities: Comparing alternative approaches to reducing the vulnerability of riverbank communities in two Indonesian cities. Environ Urban. 2015; 27: 1–16.

(117) Skogstad Sjah T, Baldwin C. Options for future effective water management in Lombok: A multi-level nested framework. J Hydrol. 2014; 519: 2448–2455.

(118) Yumarni T. Women capacity, community resilience and sustainable post disaster reconstruction: Case study from Indonesia. JIAP. 2015; 1: 28–31.

(119) Hellman J. Living with floods and coping with vulnerability. Disaster Prev. Manage. 2015; 24: 468–483.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.20886/jklh.2019.13.1.39-59

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2019 Jurnal Ecolab

This Journal Index by:

  



Copyright © Ecolab
e-ISSN: 2502-8812, p-ISSN: 1978-5860
Ecolab is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Creative Commons License